Lion vs Tiger

Discussion for anything non-gaming.
Post Reply
User avatar
A.G.
Posts: 64
Joined: Thu Aug 21, 2008 10:32 am
Favorite Game: Metal Gear Solid

Lion vs Tiger

Post by A.G. »

This has to be one of the most debated questions I've seen online. It's insane! People go nuts over this, just check the wars on YouTube!!! There seems to be A LOT of people that ask about this topic but VERY few actually know what they are talking about. First of all, the question itself CAN’T be answered for 2 reasons:

1. The two cats are very evenly matched. If there was a distinct winner then this would not be such a highly debated question.
2. Any filmed fights are between captive animals and do NOT reflect what would actually happen between wild counterparts. Behavior is just as vital in a fight as size and strength, thus captive animals are not an accurate indication.

Now let’s look at size as it is easily the most misunderstood/misquoted issue. In these debates people often say something like, “Well the Siberian tiger goes up to 700 lbs while an average lion is 400 lbs”. That’s is a very poor statement! First you are comparing an extreme size for a tiger with an average size of a lion. The fact is that no wild cat is over 700 lbs unless it’s a freak case. And yes, there have been rare instances when 700 lbs tigers were found, but for example the largest wild lion was measured at 690 lbs. So get your facts straight here, people. First of all, the Siberian tiger isn’t the giant it was made out to be in old documents, which were largely based on hunting stories. The officially research on Siberian tigers (started in 1992) states that the biggest males are only 520 lbs. The largest of the Bengal tigers, from Nepal, were measured around 530 lbs.

The bottom line here is that it doesn’t matter if you take a Siberian tiger or a Bengal, the largest of both are roughly the same size. Average male lions weigh in the low to mid 400 lbs range. The average male tigers (Bengal/Siberian) weigh in the mid to upper 400 lbs range. So, in terms of size you are looking, on AVERAGE, about 50-70 lbs difference. That’s not much in 400 lb cats. And as I said, larger size to occur and both cats have been recorded to surpass 600 lbs in the wild.

If you had lions and tigers live together in the same area, the lion would likely be the apex predator since it is a pack hunter. A solitary tiger would not be able to compete against a pride of lions. Nor would he be willing to fight a male lion one on one and risk getting injured. An injured male lion has his pride to provide him with food. An injured male tiger will starve.

So I say stop this silly debate. One on one, the winner is a 50/50 split. But in terms of coexisting in the wild the numbers game influences behavior. A male lion has no problem getting into a brawl and risk injury. A tiger can’t afford that and will likely back down, even if he’s bigger. It is also vital to factor in the lion’s mane, which makes him look much bigger from the front than he really is. It’s an intimidation technique and will work well against a solitary tiger.

What do you guys think?
METAL GEAR FOREVER 2001-2010
Image
User avatar
Dick Motorman
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 349
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2008 6:00 pm
PSN: DMotorman
Location: connecticut

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by Dick Motorman »

This reminds me of the "master cheif vs samus and/or the myriad of other opponents" threads you see all over the internet, in either case, who cares?




and samus would kick his ass btw :mrgreen:
Image
User avatar
seraphssavior
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 378
Joined: Sun Jan 21, 2007 8:01 pm

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by seraphssavior »

People arguing on youtube don't count as real people. If they're arguing about something, it's been scientifically proven that the topic of argument has no bearing on real life.
Life and Death hang in perfect balance...I'm only here to tip the scales.
User avatar
A.G.
Posts: 64
Joined: Thu Aug 21, 2008 10:32 am
Favorite Game: Metal Gear Solid

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by A.G. »

it's been scientifically proven that the topic of argument has no bearing on real life.
Well, in the case of Lion vs Tiger that's not entirely true. First of all, the two cats have (and to some degree still do) lived together in Asia. And there has been talk about introducing Tigers into Africa where they would be safer in order to increase the population and then bring them back to Asian parts. Same has been said about the EXTREMELY endangered Asiatic Lion. Some consider the notion of expanding the population out to avoid inbreeding. But that would put them out in tiger country.

So the notion of the two supercats living together isn't far fetched. And it probably the greatest question in the worlf of VS battles in the animal kingdom. Did you know that the tiger is the worlds favorite animal? It's true. Animal Planet conducted a global poll with millions of votes. The tiger beat out the dog for the first spot. The lion took 5th place.
METAL GEAR FOREVER 2001-2010
Image
User avatar
Mornaug
Posts: 20
Joined: Wed Jul 23, 2008 9:51 pm
Favorite Game: Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake
Kojima games owned: Penguin Adventure, Metal Gear (MSX), Metal Gear 2: Solid Snake, Snatcher, Policenauts, Metal Gear Solid 1-2-3, Z.O.E.
Location: Chula Vista, CA

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by Mornaug »

Only when the lion and the tiger join forces to become the Liger can one or the other be defeated.
Image
User avatar
RandommodnaR
Runner
Posts: 134
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 2:37 pm
Location: Boston Atlanta Metropolitan Axis

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by RandommodnaR »

Mornaug wrote:Only when the lion and the tiger join forces to become the Liger can one or the other be defeated.
I like how this guy thinks...
And then the long pulse of Zion Dub...
User avatar
A.G.
Posts: 64
Joined: Thu Aug 21, 2008 10:32 am
Favorite Game: Metal Gear Solid

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by A.G. »

Only when the lion and the tiger join forces to become the Liger can one or the other be defeated.
A fat, captive, timid Liger vs a wild Lion or Tiger? LOL... Yes, the Liger is gigantic, but it's fat. You take a 400 lbs lion and an 800 lbs Liger and the Liger will run away.
METAL GEAR FOREVER 2001-2010
Image
User avatar
Dick Motorman
Second Lieutenant
Posts: 349
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2008 6:00 pm
PSN: DMotorman
Location: connecticut

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by Dick Motorman »

it's always funny when people try and rationalize things that are very clearly jokes.
Image
User avatar
A.G.
Posts: 64
Joined: Thu Aug 21, 2008 10:32 am
Favorite Game: Metal Gear Solid

Re: Lion vs Tiger

Post by A.G. »

Actually the effectiveness of a Liger has been discussed in a documentary. You can get a part of it on YouTube.
METAL GEAR FOREVER 2001-2010
Image
Post Reply